Since partnering with Bloomberg Philanthropies (DNYA) we have had more of a focus on local NYC artists, especially small to mid-sized organizations and venues. Well don’t let the moniker Off-Broadway fool you, these shows might not be technically Broadway shows, but for many of them the demand and ticket prices associated with them is just as high.

Below we analyzed our theater data to determine the 10 most popular Off-Broadway shows. If you are interested in NYC theater check out our original (and much more detailed) post on Off-Broadway tickets.

Top 10 Off Broadway Shows in NYC

Off-Broadway Show Avg. Price City State
My Sinatra New York $278.25 New York NY
Something For The Boys $225.69 New York NY
Bill O’Reilly and Dennis Miller $218.00 New York NY
Sitting Pretty $215.87 New York NY
Rated P for Parenthood $207.13 New York NY
The Common Pursuit $172.00 New York NY
4000 Miles $161.27 New York NY
Old Jews Telling Jokes $157.50 New York NY
Lost In Yonkers $157.00 New York NY
Newsical The Musical $148.51 New York NY

Note updated to remove Broadway shows that were accidentally included, such as Newsies.

My Sinatra Tickets

Date
Event
Thursday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $258
Friday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $137
Saturday 8:00 PM New York, NY tickets from $139
Sunday 3:00 PM New York, NY tickets from $139
Wednesday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $124
Thursday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $119
Friday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $119
Sunday 3:00 PM New York, NY tickets from $119
Wednesday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $118
Thursday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $118
Friday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $118
Sunday 3:00 PM New York, NY tickets from $118
Wednesday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $119
Thursday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $119
Friday 7:30 PM New York, NY tickets from $137
Sunday 3:00 PM New York, NY tickets from $119